Fans Hold a ‘Grudge’ Against New Sony Film at Box Office

A new year brings the promise of new beginning and a dedication to resolutions.  Some people decide to go to the gym more, eat less saturated fats, read Horror News Network more frequently, etc.  Others make even more lofty goals, such as reserving judgment about their co-workers or neighbors.

Unfortunately for Sony Pictures, horror fans had to break some of those resolutions only a few days into the new year, as it was apparent that the vast majority of people who bought tickets to see the Sam Raimi produced The Grudge had a legitimate ax to grind over the new reboot.

The new film from director Nick Pesce (The Eyes of My Mother) and starring Andrea Riseborough, Demian Bichir, John Cho, Betty Gilpin, Lin Shaye and Jacki Weaver is estimated to finish in fourth or fifth place at the weekend box office with roughly $12 million in ticket sales, but the reactions being generated by The Grudge are truly horrifying.

The Grudge became one of a select few (less than 20 films since 1979) to earn the dubious grade of “F” from opening night polling company Cinemascore.  Coupled with 19% on Rotten Tomatoes Tomatometer and an identical 19% audience score (which could very well be an early sign of the Apocalypse), the news for anyone involved in this production is as about as dark as the hair of any supernatural child in the history of J-Horror.

RelishMix (via Deadline), another company that monitors fan reactions and online buzz concerning new films, made an astute point about horror fans, stating that “Fans of horror films are established as some of the most loyal and discussion prone of all genres – and The Grudge proves that sentiment with fans comparing this version to early ones, both made in the U.S. and Japan.  But, even fans have issues with this latest version of the Grudge movies.  The consensus of fans and more casual moviegoers alike is how can another one of these films be made ‘so soon.’  It seems like there’s a limit in the audience’s mind for some film franchises – beloved as they are – that sometimes it’s just too soon for another entry.  Plus, this version has not helped itself with its confusing messaging as to the very plot line.  Even horror fans are asking, is this a remake, a reboot, or some kind of chapter in between the originals?  And… ‘where is Sarah Michelle Geller’, as she might be receiving more convo than any cast member from this 2020 version.”  This thesis is supported by the fact that nearly 60% of the films that have received an “F” grade from Cinemascore are horror films, including such maligned movies as Lost Souls, Fear Dot Com, Alone in the Dark, and The Devil Inside.  

With a busy horror schedule in the months of January and February (including next week’s Kristen Stewart led denizens of the deep film, Underwater), don’t expect The Grudge to last long.  In fact, its only chance at a few more dollars may be motivated by a morbid curiosity, with people buying tickets to confirm that the quality is “as advertised”.

Be sure to check out our annual guide to all of the winter horror releases, and come back next week to see if Underwater suffers a similar fate at the Box Office.




Nick Banks
Nick Banks
Nick joined the website in 2015. His lifelong love of comics and horror began with Universal Monsters and the Incredible Hulk. He has fond memories of going to Waldbaum’s supermarket with his mother and being rewarded with a 3-pack of sealed comics. It’s been all downhill from there… Since those early days, his life has been immersed in four color action and scares on the silver screen.

Similar Articles


Latest News

Will Epic ‘Godzilla vs. Kong’ Battle Go To A Streamer?

The monster knock-down-drag-out all horror fans have been salivating for may skip the big screen and instead appear on a streamer--or it may show...

Eli Roth’s Crypt TV Begins Production On ‘Chhori’

Eli Roth’s Crypt TV, in association with Blumhouse, has added more players to the cast of its Hindi horror film Chhori. Mita Vashisht, Rajesh...

‘Dark Shadows’ Scribe Malcolm Marmorstein Passes Away

Malcolm Marmorstein--a major player in the success of the 1960s horror soap opera Dark Shadows--passed away this week at the age of 92. Marmorstein--who also had big-screen...

‘The Reef’ Director Plunging Ahead With Plans For Sequel

Just in time for swimming season next year, filmmaker Andrew Traucki plans to make you very afraid to go into the water. Sporting the unsettling...

‘Run’ Sets Hulu Record

Sarah Paulson continues to have a monstrous 2020 as her latest film, Run, has set a record at Hulu for the streamers most watched...

Newsletter Sign-Up

Subscribe to our newsletter

Our bi-monthly newsletter consists of the latest horror news and CT HorrorFest happenings.

Site Sponsors